Join us for a thought-provoking debate featuring Bret Weinstein as he delves into the existence of God and various related topics. This civil discourse covers a wide array of subjects, from evolution and moral judgment to the complexities of consciousness and the creation of the universe.
Chapters:
- 0:00 Introduction
- 1:18 Debating Evolution
- 10:54 Is Human Sacrifice Evidence of the Supernatural?
- 19:33 Consciousness vs. Intuition
- 28:02 Weinstein’s Explanation for Creation
- 32:10 Evidence of Human Evolution
- 40:30 Moral Judgment Without God
- 47:42 Weinstein on Jesus Christ
- 51:13 Complexity of the Universe and Intelligent Design
- 58:37 Critique of Sam Harris as an Atheist Spokesperson
- 1:06:03 The Realities of the Middle East
- 1:20:03 Focus on Foreign vs. Domestic Issues
- 1:29:24 Is the Debate on Israel Manufactured?
- 1:40:57 Challenges to Honest Conversations
- 1:50:48 COVID Vaccine Discussions
- 1:57:08 Removing the COVID Shot from the Vaccine Schedule
- 1:59:03 Insights on Vaccine Injuries
- 2:10:15 AI and Consciousness
- 2:16:12 Preventing Dangerous AI Evolution
- 2:20:18 Weinstein’s Outlook for the West
Engage in this compelling discussion that challenges conventional thinking across multiple dimensions of society and belief.
Do you have feedback for The Tucker Carlson Show? We want to hear your thoughts. https://watchtcn.co/43i1o80
Great discussion!
Parsimony does not necessitate evolution. How is evolution a simple model?
I ask if evolution is the answer why haven't endangered species of animals and plants broken down on a cellular level and become something other than what they are????
1:06:06 Wow, hes really confused about Islam here. As if islam was an evolutionary process!
The phrase "radical" Islam is incorrect. It would be like saying a "radical" Christian donates to the poor and tries to love their enemy.
Its what we were called to do!
Islam was called to enslave the world, and to kill those that refuse.
Its not radical, its what the Koran tells them to do. The Muslims that dont do it are just lazy Muslims, just like there are lazy christians.
I wish so bad that I could believe in a god and in all these amazing things Tucker is talking about, I've truly searched for a meaning in life after several overdoses, been on life support etc. But I just can't "make" myself believe in that a god created all this, which is truly painful and I seriously truly wish that I could convince myself because I need a meaning..
Evolution is a process that itself evolves so why don't we see things evolving all around us, or why did it just remain at its same pace, slow down, or even stop
My belief is that the efforts of science are usefu up to a certain point demonstrated in everyday life in areas like medicine for example. I also believe that science is limited by multiple factors in ever discovering the truth about everything. At some point our human abilities limit us from correctly analyzing scientific findings accurately or even setting up the correct conditions for experiments without error. Even with the help of AI at some point even with the help of AI how can we even verify after a certain point if what AI is telling us is accurate? Science claims to be able to reproduce results in the same exact conditions to prove a hypothesis or disprove a hypothesis. But how are the conditions ever EXACTLY the same since the exact time and position of all objects in the universe aren't constant when experiment is reproduced to check for consistent results.
In order to say "the Creator must have a creator" is not just absurd—it’s cosmically misguided. To make that claim, you'd need access to all knowable knowledge in existence—and, my friend, Mr. Weinstein is currently 3,000 miles from Graceland with no map, no shoes, and a banjo with one string. This is like a blind man trying to navigate a Himalayan cliffside in flip-flops during monsoon season. And with that, my friend… you have no case.
!
Loved this civil conversation. I'm not sure the evolution argument was actually addressed but I appreciated Bret's willingness to honor the utility of the core beliefs of billions of people. I value Tuckers representations but I think his assessments of god are misinformed by prejudice and patronage.
God invented evolution.
Bret, you are wonderful
Grew up Christian, and moved away as I developed in my 20s.
I'm now a father, and feel regardless of my questions/concerns, society would benefit from believing in a God, and that's good enough for me for now
MACRO evolution is impossible. You'd have to toss the laws of Science–Laws of thermodynamics.
Bret has it totally right at ~7:30. If a creator wanted to create the huge variety of life that we seem wouldn't natural selection for useful variation be the most genius idea?
Also, people confuse 'survival of the fittest' vs survival of the strongest. Darwin wrote in the 19th Century, when 'fit' meant what it does now in legal terms – Fit for Purpose i.e suitable for the situation/environment
"being of that mindset." The Jews are hardly the only group to have experienced anything horrific. This "Generational Trauma" argument is utter nonsense, at least in the biological sense. It's taught, generation to generation, resulting in a sub-culture that deliberately avoids fully assimilating and historically creates a nation within a nation. This ultimately results in a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Tucker -Tucker I love your ALPS ! Bret will never get it with his super Human Brain ! He is Lost ! Pray for him and move on ! TUCKER: No more Air Time to help him turn people from Jesus Christ ! I have watched every one of your interviews but I cannot get through this one and I am sure millions of people have clicked off ! I never leave comments but you know the holy spirit feeling yourself and that is what is typing my keys , I think you are great & we need you, Do not stop what you do Please !
Tucker, like many religious people, say he can't figure out why people are moral without a God-given moral code. So is Tucker constantly restraining himself from murder and rape because God told him it's wrong? Most people, religious or not, object to murder. People have empathy for other people so they don't wish to harm them. They might even try to help someone. This happens all the time without Divine intervention.
South Park put it best IMO.
"Evolution could be the answer to HOW, not the answer to WHY."
The ‘modern west’ basis for collaboration is destroying us.
The Bible says you don't have the capacity to understand everything yet. Don't try to prove everything with books and science, just believe, for your own sake.
If you can go forward infinity then you can go backwards infinity. It’s called a loop. We are either the product of a loop or everything started from a being with no beginning. Both are just as crazy but due to dimensions and all types of things the creator is more likely
Two of my favorite people in the whole world ❤️
Absolutely incredible discussion. James Lindsey will call this "woke right"…
This guy sucks
A wise man once said 'facts do not care about your feelings'. So if all evidence points to a Godless universe, it doesn't matter if that makes you sad.
36:45 so language is now evolution? 😂